Title

Wednesday, August 02, 2006

Sillunnu Oru Kadhal

Disclaimer: To ask me to write a restrained review for a Rahman album, is like asking a school kid to sit a minute after the bell has gone on the last day before summer vacation.

The lowlies:
Let's get the songs that got out of my playlist pretty soon, out of the way. Mazaa Mazaa is Rahman caught in a SJ Surya warp. Nothing special, nothing out of the ordinary, nothing worth mentioning except the fact that Shreya does a spectacular job of making tamil sound like telugu...or wait...was it meant to be telugu? Also, Charan is wasted, especially(I say this at the risk of committing the greatest blasphemy in TFM) when he is just beginning to sound a wee bit like his illustrous dad.

I would have been pretty disappointed with Mareecham, had it not been redeemed by a what I have come to notice as a new Rahman trait-transitions. Well, this is something that struck me in Rang De Basanti, in both the title song and Khalbali. Both had such-if I may be audacious enough to say so-pedestrian beginnings but then came the awesome transitions- a subtle yet impactful pace and tone change in the former and the ziddi and the hone hone de nasha bits in the latter- which ended up giving a whole new dimension to what would have been ordinary songs. Here too, Rahman uses the male vocals and some chants to provide a foil to Caroline's husky sultry rendition making it sound pretty decent.

The Contenders:
The title song that is bound to end up being popular did not impress me too much. It was Ilayarajayish in the fact that the jazz arrangements sounded like what was used in Kurangu Kayil Maalai (Mumbai Express) and also that the vocals were similar to Kaaka(Julie Ganapathy). Neverthless, Rahman does some neat experimentation and this ends up being pretty much in the league of Hello Mr. Edhir Katchi(Iruvar).

Shankar Mahadevan pulls off a Uppu Karuvaadu with Machakaari and Vasundhra Das does a great job too. A peppy racy pace, interesting interludes make this a sure fire chartbuster.

The Upper Echelon:
Kummi Adi, what a fabulous energetic beginning to the album. Rahman gets everything right, from the eclectic mix of voices(The folksy rustic Seerkazhi Siva Chidambaram and Theni Kunjaramma and the tempering effect of Swarnalatha and Naresh) and the meticulous attention to the rythm,that is essentially life of this song. When this song ends with that no holds barred, barrage of beats, you just don't want it to!

Nirvana:
Ah! The irony of genius! When something you create competes with something else you create! If there is anything called a vintage Rahman duet, Munbe Vaa fits that description to a tee. Shreya and Naresh are at their sublime best, add to that the refreshing Rangoli chorus, and the cross between a santoor and jalatarang instrumentals, and you have sheer class. Just when you thought things can't get any better, as if to question that very thought, Rahman belts out New York Nagaram, the mindblowing way he starts the song with the guitar and that half mumble-half hum , Tanvi and Bhargavi's harmony, the echo of voices at the end of each line, that aching, soulful love ballad feel- just pure unadulterated pleasure!

Well that's my first take, bound to be some changes considering the tendency of his music to grow on you. Just when I was floundering about in blog drought, I hear this album and the words start flowing and a post is born in no time. What better life saver can a drowning man ask for? Drought, Drowning....hmmmm...logical disconnect...but you get the picture...

13 Comments:

Blogger DeaK.In.FroSt said...

Very amusing dude..enjoyed every expression you poured over the song...great job

10:09 AM, August 04, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Surprisingly, I find myself appreciating Munbe Vaa and New York. ARR just went a page ahead in my book with the sublime, subdued instrumentation in these two songs.

The beautifully strummed acoustic guitar that makes "New York" very classy, as does the totally awesome singing. Heck, I'll say it - this song rocks. \m/

5:36 PM, August 04, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Dreamer...

ARR's songs have ARR written ALL over it...and with the two i heard i can't say that...

Naresh has an amazing voice i should say...I think that lifted up the song Munbe Vaa more than anything else...overall I didn't like the song too much though...

NY Nagaram is a totally different story...The contrast is weird don't u think...The thin thread that holds songs of an artist together like a theme from which everything else flows jus doesn't exist between these two songs...

But NY Nagaram its a great song... I love it...very soothing...its awesome!!

2:47 AM, August 05, 2006  
Blogger Karthik said...

hi dreamer..

it would be easier on the eye if you toned down your saffron images on the left. am finding it difficult to read.

reg. jillunu.. itself,munbe vaa and new york nagaram are competing with each other for the top of my list too..

3:16 PM, August 06, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

DeaK.In.Frost,
Thanks!

I-dont-know-who-you-are,
ARR went a page ahead in your book? He just happens to be half the title page on mine:) The other half is Raja...;)

Now-I-Know-who-you-are,

Even if I din't know who you were, the complicated construction of the second line of your comment is a dead give away:) Had to read it thrice to get it.
Anyway Munbe Vaa is a song that will grow on you, you just wait and hear. NY is the kind of song that impresses you in one hearing, but Munbe Vaa will take its time.

I don't think the contrast is weird. I belong to the class of people who view change, contradiction, inconsistency as inevitable human traits;) The thing I actually like about Rahman is his ability to change himself according to the type of song he composes. So if you see a major difference between the feel of the two songs, I see that as a good thing:)

Karthik,

I have been real lazy to fix that thing. But as far as I can see it affects only certain browser settings, where the text overlaps with the image. I will get that fixed soon...don't want to be callous to the needs of my microscopic reader population:)

12:57 AM, August 07, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

'New York' thavura feeelings illey baa mattha paatla ... nallaa osthiyaana tuneaa poda sollu thaleevara ... unnun oru naalu pageu munna poraaraa paakalaam. Title pagekelaamm vara time aagum kannu, sollikinene kandukko! nee innaa venaa solliko, mottai mottai thaan.

3:47 PM, August 07, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

the-original-you-know-who-i-am...

Mamae,
Summakatti edhanaachu solladhe...oru dhaba kettuttu feelings illenna....nalanju vaati kelu baaa ellaaam thanaa varum. Mottai music ottu veedu maadhiri romba simpulu....once timelaye effectu vandhudum...aana nammaaalu flooru mela flooru kattidam maadhiri...oru vaati ketta ella floorum paarka mudiyaadhu:)
Appala Manasa thirandhukinnu ketta ellaa feelingsum varum baaa...nee manasukkulla mottaiya vechikunnu ketttinnaaa eppadi baa?

1:56 PM, August 08, 2006  
Blogger shakuni said...

gummi adi: seriyaana start.
new york nagaram: seriyaana start
charan does sound a lot like spb. where the fuck was his voice hiding!!

maththa padi, specialaa onnum illa.
nee pesama poi kumbida pona dheivam paattu kelu. thoda mudiyadhu adha ellam.

10:19 PM, August 17, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mr. Nadadhur,

As we greatly respect your judgement and value your opinions, we would like to request you to review the following 'tamizh' films:

Kadhal
Thirupathchi
Thambi

Sincerely,
Murari and Prem

7:04 PM, August 20, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

he he...@ my dear anonymous friends...:) can i add to that list??

Kushi
Bose
Thiruda Thirudi

Yours truly,
me!!!

6:54 PM, August 21, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

Shakuni,

What do you mean 'Sariyana Start'? Rest of the song? Anyway, I think 4/7 is a good score for any album. As for 'Kumbida Pona Dheivam' paatu, i searched for a Ilayaraja song with the same name and ultimately found a Devisree Prasad/Mani Sharma/Dhina song from Thirupaachi. If that is what you are referring to, I guess its no surprise you did not like this album.

Murari and Prem,

I am sorry I cannot cater to your requests ever as
I have no intention of seeing two of the movies in that list.

I already have a review of Kadhal up on this blog.You can check it out if you want. I am not surprised that the two of you did not like the movie. The probable reason is best explained in the spectacular opening paragraphs of this review of Pudhupettai by Baradwaj Rangan http://brangan.easyjournal.com/entry.aspx?eid=2953155.
Though he talks about Selvaraghavan, I think that can be well applied to movies like Autograph and Kadhal.

Anyway sarcasm appreciated.

me,

Othu Oodhara/Jalra sarcasm does not deserve the respect sarcasm gets. So I shall pass.

8:59 PM, August 21, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

how mean!!! how rude!!! :( sniff sniff

10:26 AM, August 27, 2006  
Blogger mucastic said...

And another bonhomie I missed?

2:55 PM, September 29, 2006  

Post a Comment

<< Home