Title

Saturday, November 18, 2006

Guru

Forgive me my readers, for it is that time again- the time when you groan and go “Oh no! Not again! Not yet another superlative, adjective filled, Rahman worshipping review”. Try as I might to be objective, and brave the onslaught of the waves, it is all in vain as I break down and give in to this man and fall to my knees and bow to him. Now that I am done with the theatrics, let me dispense with the unpleasant first.

There is something comforting about familiarity, which is why we tend to associate anything new with something we know well. Right from telling someone you meet that they remind you of someone else, to trying hard to find out which old song a new one resembles, we try to mentally map the unfamiliar with the accustomed. Rahman gives you a million opportunities to do this, for he extensively reuses bits and pieces of his old compositions to give you something pseudo-new, yet mind blowing. Moreover, he uses a lot of commercially available loops which explains why some of his beats sound “lifted” from somewhere. To me, this is not a sign of creative saturation, but rather it showcases his ability to reuse the familiar and conjure up something phenomenal. To give you an analogy, there is this scene in The Mask, when Jim Carrey pulls out balloons and twists them into all kinds of shapes. When you see the final shapes that evolve, you don’t sit and complain that it’s the same damn balloon that made all of them. Actually, the analogy sucked, but I hope you see the connection anyway.

So coming back to the music of Guru- Yes I agree. Dum Dhara does sound like the Gayatri Mantra for it is inherently hymn like in intonation; A fifteen second flute bit in Mayya Mayya is probably from some Buddha Bar album and Satrangi Re makes a presence too; Ay Hairathe starts off like Poo Kodiyin(Iruvar) and uses a bit from Ye Rishta(Meenaxi); Ek Lo Ek Muft has a beat uncannily similar to Ayyo Pathikichu(Rhythm); There is a hint of the Bombay theme in Jaage Hain. If the songs didn’t impress you because of a few reused bits, then you are just nitpicking. If the songs impressed you and the reused bits still bother you, didn’t you hear perfection is overrated?

Guru had kept me edgy and nervous all this week. I have lost count of the number of websites I have scrounged for updates, and the number of times I have refreshed the browser. And when the samples came out, I was floored by Tere Bina, welcomed back with a pleased familiarity- Hariharan in Ay Hairathe, piqued by the exotic Maryem Toller in Mayya Mayya, and hastily dismissed off Barso Re. But these were mere mortals, and when I saw the credits for Jaage Hain, that had Chitra, Rahman and the Madras Choral Group, I smacked my lips for I knew that would be what I really wanted. And when I heard Rahman’s off-key whisper, to the accompaniment of those soulful strings, I knew he was teasing me as if to say “You have waited so long, wait a little more”. And then the eruption of the high pitched vocals, followed up by that spell binding chorus- ecstasy! What a moving, emotionally sapping composition. There are two kinds of anticipation, one when you don’t know what you are getting; the other when you know exactly what you are getting. Usually, there is no fun in the latter, but the thing about Jaage Hain is that it makes even that so much fun. You know Rahman is going to break out in that now-familiar vocals, and you know the choir is going to repeat after him, and yet you eagerly wait, as though standing in a beach waiting for the waves to come and soak you.

And the lyrics though sparse are so evocative- Gulzar’s sequel to Robert Frost’s “Miles to go before I sleep” is “Miles have gone by. Let me sleep”. Rahman mentioned in an interview that the music starts off with a Turkish feel, moves on to become “north Indian friendly” and then operatic. So this is likely to be the climax song a la Malarodu from Bombay. By the way did you notice the classy touch -the faint bagpipes when Rahman whispers?

Tere Bina, Rahman’s ode to Nusrat and what an ode at that. Widening his singing repertoire, he attempts a romantic duet, probably for the first time and pulls it off with such finesse. You can almost feel the childish excitement when Rahman starts an ambitious Ga Ga Ri Sa like Nusrat's flurry of notes in Afreen Afreen, and then checks himself and falls back to a simple Luka Chuppi like style. But the highlight of the song for me is Chinmayee. It is one thing to be talented, it is an entirely different thing to constantly challenge yourself and push the envelope. Singing with tremendous versatility, she steals the thunder from Rahman especially when she alternates between low and high pitches in the end.

Ay Hairathe, the return of the prodigal son. Hariharan makes a comeback to his comfort zone in this melodious Ghazalish duet. Hey wait, there is fodder for all you Rahman nay sayers. The Dum Dhara chorus is lifted from somewhere. Oh right, its from Tere Bina. Tch Tch, recycling tunes in the same movie. That’s a first even by Rahman standards. Anyway, I am assuming the two songs are linked in some way in the movie.

To many people living in North India, anyone from the south is a Madrasi. I would have made a similarly misinformed generalization and branded Mayya Mayya as Arabian sounding, had I not read that it in fact has Turkish influences. With an infectious rhythm, Maryem Toller’s sultry voice, and the Holida interlude by Keerthi to die for, this is the pick of the peppy numbers. Rahman experiments big time with Baazi Laga which is the “north Indian friendly” number. Keeping in mind that Guru is a period film, this is the only song from a different time in the album. Rahman has always been among the few music directors to give the backing vocalists their due and recognition. I loved the way he uses Swetha and Bhargavi in that catchy chorus.

Barso Re, for me has a disappointing start but redeems itself very nicely in the next two stanzas. Ek Lo Ek Muft has the funny Joiyyun Joiyyun chorus which is actually nice to hear. But for once I am not impressed with Rahman’s pick of vocals. Bappida though doing exactly what is expected of him does not lend anything special to the song. When Rahman usually does the music equivalent of a casting coup, he has always produced songs to remember-MSV in Aalalakanda(Sangamam) and Vidai Kodu(Kannathil Muthamittal) and why even, Silambarasan in Bailamore(Kaadhal Virus). In all likelihood, Barso Re and Ek Lo are likely to make a better impact on screen, which is a given considering that the former boasts of Ash in Adirampally;)

So let me try ending this a little different. If I had to survive a week on a deserted island, I would consider an iPod loaded with the songs of Guru, and back up batteries essential to my survival. Of course, I would need food and water, but we were talking about essentials…Right?

22 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Y(et)A(nother)Post from Dreamer! Where do you find the enthu (I know you have the time, hehe!) to write such longish posts? If you can give an answer that doesn't say 'Music inspires me' I promise to listen to Guru this week :)

Any idea if a tamil version is out?

2:54 PM, November 19, 2006  
Blogger Rahmanic said...

Nice review dude...enjoyed reading ur review.Drop at
http://rahmanic.blogspot.com

4:35 AM, November 20, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice review!.

5:58 AM, November 20, 2006  
Blogger Sundar Ramanathan said...

gud one

6:48 AM, November 20, 2006  
Blogger G said...

Gosh, yes, those damn bagpipes are awesome. Haha. Loved your review.

3:51 PM, November 20, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

psrivats,

Since you snatched away an obvious response, I guess the fact that I have to say all I want to say decides the length of my posts. I think listening to Guru is enough reason for you to listen to Guru:) No bribes.
I don't think there is a tamil version.

Rahmanic, Anonymous, Sundar and Truly Rahmantic,

Thanks a lot!

4:56 PM, November 20, 2006  
Blogger Jay said...

Hey
Have been a passive reader for ages now. And after the guru onslaught that has hooked me on to the comp for the last few days, i decided to drop at ur blog for that review..and it was there!
Totally liked the way you attacked those doubting thomases...
And yes, ARR is back to his best - thankfully...
Cant wait for the movie..
A few observations on the songs -
Ay hairathe has ARR returning to his zubeidaa, Bhagat Singh mode - those delightful numbers he produced 5 yrs back! was missing them...yeah bose had some of them...but still..
and Totally had the same feelings on repeated Jaage hain loops..
Baazi laga is a let down honestly...
The Bappi song - strongly agree with all u said, but this song actually grew on me especially with its female parts..in the second charanam parts..
And ARR, Chinmayee - Strong max in Tere bina...Chinmayee has sung a good number in Veiyil too..
Rock on da - strong review..keep posting!

5:18 PM, November 20, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Its good to know that its easy to please everyones musical pallete so easily man. I felt like it was a crappy album and no "it wont grown on me". I am and will be a Rahman fan..but he is no good these days and face it.

BTW your review was better than the music.

5:53 PM, November 20, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hmm...Nice review...I agree with Suchi that the review is better than the music...Only mayya and Ye hairathe received my approval...:) Maybe others require repeated listening...

11:40 AM, November 21, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

Jay,

It took me a few seconds to realise it was you!:) As for Baazi Laga, I like it a lot because of a lot of things- Rahman trying to be unlike himself, the lalalaila interlude, the Aaahaa chorus and so on. The song is intentionally old styled, and thats probably why it is not instantly appealing.Thanks for readin...Keep Commenting!

Suchi,
I have to repeat the cliche that it is all subjective. I eat my cake, you eat yours and its all good:) There is no facing it, accepting it, agreeing with it etc...
As for the review being better than the music, though I don't remotely agree, I am flattered:)


Madhavi,
Thanks! I think the last line in your comment summarises things. I think your opinion will change with time, just like it did for Munbe Vaa.

3:41 PM, November 21, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ok..let me repeat my cliche again too! There is a thin line between being a 'fanboi' and being realistic. The cake that you are eating is from 'Bangalore Iyengar Bakery'..but the way you relish it makes it seem as though it is from 'Cake shop of the Taj'.

I meant to say "it wont grow on me" in my previous comment btw.

7:47 PM, November 21, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

he he Kaushik, ur flattered by Suchi's comment cuz u are placing Guru on a pedestal and someone said ur review was better than that..:) but some of us (maybe just me??) dont put Guru on a pedestal and so the comparison is not really between two superlatives...ha ha!! j/k...

apram? why dont u write next abt something other than ARR's music...puuhhleeese!!!

11:55 AM, November 22, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

also, u said u mentioned the ashoka connection in here? whr is it? huh? or am i missin it somewhere...the part in the beginning and the last piece of music of Mayya Mayya is EXACTLY from ashoka...raat ka nasha if i'm not mistaken or perhaps san sanana...

7:47 PM, November 22, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

suchi,

You just redefined subjectivity. For me Bangalore Iyengar Bakery's cake kicks Taj's cake's ass. For you it doesn't. Let us just agree to disagree.

madhavi,

I must admit this is one of your best comments to date. I was trying to snatch a compliment when there was probably none intended.
As for the Mayya Mayya bit, I heard it is from some Buddha Bar album and I have mentioned it. I believe Asoka also used the same bit. I also heard that Ranjit Barot was the additional programmer for both, which explains the connection.

2:16 AM, November 26, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You know that is friggin not true..you would drool your ass out even today if i give you one from CSOTT while you it will be the contrary if it would be from BIB..i said BIB and not Primas! Anyway lets carry this discussion offline..(does it always have to end with food?)

6:01 PM, November 26, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

suchi,

haha....it obviously has to end with food:) Anyway I will be eating at all these places and more in Dec...just wanted to rub it in:)

madhavi,
I forgot to add....3 out of my last 10 posts have been on Rahman. You are complaining because you are not reading my blog properly or because you have a bias towards reading Rahman reviews. If it is the latter, why complain?:)

9:22 PM, November 26, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

lol...i'm not exactly complaining...:) jus said that cuz 2 out of ur last 3 posts were about ARR...of course u can only write as much ARR reviews as his music albums..."thankfully" i might add :)

2:58 PM, November 28, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

madhavi,

2 out of 3 v/s 3 out of 10....hmmm....could this be a classic case of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selection_bias

hmm....you made me realise I write about Rahman only when there is an album. Interesting..what if I write about him just like that....haha...just kidding!

3:17 PM, November 29, 2006  
Blogger Rudra said...

late a vanthalum latesta varuven!!

by the by mr.kaushik, you write the most scinitllatingly magnificent ARR reviews everrrrr!!!

1:23 PM, December 06, 2006  
Blogger Prem said...

hey jilpa,

nice post...though I just read the 1st 2 lines.. didnt have the patience to read further..
Its too boring..

7:11 PM, December 16, 2006  
Blogger Qalandar said...

Excellent review bro!

9:50 PM, December 31, 2006  
Blogger Dreamer said...

Rudra,

Thanks;)

Prem,

I understand.

Qalandar,

Thanks a lot!

10:48 PM, January 02, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home